Fushigi Yuugi Mafia (CLOSED - TOWNIES WINS!)

I can't whistle.  

hhvenus wrote:I can't whistle.  

 

The wait is killing me.

 

I seriously cried while typing this death up T_T

*Throws hands in the air* Of course Night 1 ends when I'm about to leave!

Cop claim! Doc's alive!

Sorry Ayu I had to wait for a power role PM before I could end the night phase

Not your fault, Ari. Hmm... Doc is a live, Cop is alive. That's good for us. Now to figure out who is mafia.

Nooo zodia! We will avenge you!

 

Heading out now. I'll be back later!

No cop claims yet?

at this point only Kyra or swifty can claim cop.

Zodiac! x_x

((... or we could keep hiding the cop in case lucky mafia kills poor doctor and trust that cop could keep themselves alive while sneakily ferreting information?))

Hmm... for being impatient with the Cop Claiming their role, I vote Natasha!

natasha you seem to like to claim cop quickly in these games?

Woah night ended? See what I miss when I start writing.

These games are small enough to be like epicmafia. If you do not claim cop outright when the doctor is alive then you miss out on figuring out on innocents. If a noncop counterclaims then you get either the other mafia, or an innocent.

Besides, the doc could die the next night and then you miss the chance and the cop may end up dying anyways. hh could claim cop, forgot she was playing. xD

I believe Kyra may be mafia at this point for voting me. A villager would want to know who is innocent via cop at this point. If not, they don't know how to play small games.

Kyra

Claiming cop at first is important because the doc can prevent them being murdered by mafia. We get another innocent that way as well.

natashasurgirl wrote:These games are small enough to be like epicmafia. If you do not claim cop outright when the doctor is alive then you miss out on figuring out on innocents. If a noncop counterclaims then you get either the other mafia, or an innocent.

Besides, the doc could die the next night and then you miss the chance and the cop may end up dying anyways. hh could claim cop, forgot she was playing. xD

I believe Kyra may be mafia at this point for voting me. A villager would want to know who is innocent via cop at this point. If not, they don't know how to play small games.

Kyra

^.~ Or you could look at earlier games and see that my first day vote is typically random based on who I personally like XD

Personally, I would highly suggest not lynching me right now.

natashasurgirl wrote:Claiming cop at first is important because the doc can prevent them being murdered by mafia. We get another innocent that way as well.

IDK, I think having cop claim in the beginning makes the game way less fun. It makes it quicker, no doubt, but now the doctor doesn't really get to play - it's a job rather than a game.

I know you are not cop, Kyra. Also, randomly voting is typically non-townie behavior. A non-townie would lynch while it would be smarter of townies to no lynch if they are unsure. Our first game you voted for me as cop because you found out I was mafia with that reasoning. I am not mafia this time. Your random voting gives me every reason not to trust you as a townie.

The doctor's role is to save lives. You are suggesting more anti-town behavior. By not claiming while the doctor is alive gives mafia the opportunity to hope that the doctor guesses wrong on who mafia will kill. The only person who matters in this game for doctor to save is cop.

If we were in a bigger game i'd wait, but that's not the case here. Besides I kind of want to keep my winning streak, and also the beginner games are to teach people how to play intermediate games.

natashasurgirl wrote:I know you are not cop, Kyra. Also, randomly voting is typically non-townie behavior. A non-townie would lynch while it would be smarter of townies to no lynch if they are unsure. Our first game you voted for me as cop because you found out I was mafia with that reasoning. I am not mafia this time. Your random voting gives me every reason not to trust you as a townie.

The doctor's role is to save lives. You are suggesting more anti-town behavior. By not claiming while the doctor is alive gives mafia the opportunity to hope that the doctor guesses wrong on who mafia will kill. The only person who matters in this game for doctor to save is cop.

If we were in a bigger game i'd wait, but that's not the case here. Besides I kind of want to keep my winning streak, and also the beginner games are to teach people how to play intermediate games.

>p Fine, you guys can all vote for me and off a townie. GC players know this is how I play first day - it might not be the best move with these small games, but I hate voting not to lynch on the first day because it puts us two townies down with nothing to show for it and just makes day two what day one should have been - random votes and theories with notices on whom voted for whom and what evidence or hunches were cited in those votes.

natashasurgirl wrote:I know you are not cop, Kyra.

Is this you telling us that you're the cop and you're just scum fishing?

Kyralih wrote:>p Fine, you guys can all vote for me and off a townie. GC players know this is how I play first day - it might not be the best move with these small games, but I hate voting not to lynch on the first day because it puts us two townies down with nothing to show for it and just makes day two what day one should have been - random votes and theories with notices on whom voted for whom and what evidence or hunches were cited in those votes.

But it's not random if we know who cop is. We have 1 cop and either a mafia or innocent villager.

Now we have you admitting to neither cop nor doctor. You can only be mafia or townie at this point. If you are in fact townie, then there can only be 1 more.

Kyralih wrote:

natashasurgirl wrote:I know you are not cop, Kyra.

Is this you telling us that you're the cop and you're just scum fishing?

I didn't say that. I told you, your behavior screams scummy to me. Besides, it seems pretty silly to kill the person who also claimed cop first day last game.

We need a bunny that is eating popcorn. XD

Last words: Reading through the thread, I'm trusting Natasha at this point.

I second the motion for a bunny eating popcorn!