My-HiME Mafia (Townies WIN)

AgentAyu wrote:

SenshiRei wrote:Well that's good, at least the cop managed to find a townie. Unless of course, the framer was in action. I don't think we can take anything for absolute fact in this game - lets presume Ari is innocent, but remember that she might very well not be.

If Ari was Framer she would have appeared Guilty to the Cop. And since she didn't appear guilty, that confirms she is 100% Innocent who was NOT framed last night. She's either vanilla or bodyguard we don't know.

That leaves:

Rei (Mai)
Yami (Yukino)
Ayu (Natsuki)
Natasha (Yukariko)
Thunder (Midori)
Ari (Akira) - Innocent

5 of us are unconfirmed if we're vanilla or one of the three power roles (1 Bodyguard, 1 Mafia, and 1 Framer).

Ayu it's 1 Body Guard, 2 Mafia, and 1 framer unless I missed something during the game granted being sick it wouldn't surprise me any if I did.

ok so i have a question, what happens if we kill the two actual mafia, and the framer is left? do townies win? or does mafia win?

 because framer cant kill, right? so i'd assume townies win at that point, but im not sure.

Ari-Chan wrote:

AgentAyu wrote:

SenshiRei wrote:Well that's good, at least the cop managed to find a townie. Unless of course, the framer was in action. I don't think we can take anything for absolute fact in this game - lets presume Ari is innocent, but remember that she might very well not be.

If Ari was Framer she would have appeared Guilty to the Cop. And since she didn't appear guilty, that confirms she is 100% Innocent who was NOT framed last night. She's either vanilla or bodyguard we don't know.

That leaves:

Rei (Mai)
Yami (Yukino)
Ayu (Natsuki)
Natasha (Yukariko)
Thunder (Midori)
Ari (Akira) - Innocent

5 of us are unconfirmed if we're vanilla or one of the three power roles (1 Bodyguard, 1 Mafia, and 1 Framer).

Ayu it's 1 Body Guard, 2 Mafia, and 1 framer unless I missed something during the game granted being sick it wouldn't surprise me any if I did.

That's what I was thinking too, Ari, but that would mean the game would be over wouldn't it? Since Framer is mafia aligned who is participating in the mafia meetings. That would have us at 3 Mafia Aligned and 3 Townie Aligned.

Light, could you please further explain how the Mafia v. Townie count goes for this game with the Framer involved?

the framer is mafia. I don't understand light's rule on that to be honest. The framer should be able to converse with mafia and help vote to kill. That's the way it is on Epicmafia, and we follow epicmafia rules.


There should only be 1 mafia, and 1 framer mafia in this setup. In fact his role list even says that. 


Rei (Mai)
Yami (Yukino)
Ayu (Natsuki)
Natasha (Yukariko)- Innocent
Thunder (Midori)
Ari (Akira) - Innocent




I usually hate lynching on the first day. It's usually something mafia would do. However, we know ari is innocent, I am a townie. If we lynch one, and even if it's a mislynch, then when mafia kills we have narrowed it down to 2 only possibilities of mafia the next day. 


We can always save our lynch for tomorrow though, which means we are less likely to kill townie or a body guard. And actually I just looked over the list again and it's a bad idea. 


Let's let mafia widdle us down a little bit so we can make a proper decision. 


My suspicions?


One of them is AgentAyu. I'm keeping an eye on Thunder, but I don't get the feeling he is mafia. (I can be wrong.) I'm also a lil bit suspicious of Senshirei. This is what my gut is saying. If any of the three of them live... that makes me extremely suspicious.


Let's wait until it's a lynch or no lynch situation to lynch. (That's day 3)


No Lynch

and the reason I changed my mind is because I suck at math.

Light, can you clarify on mafia members please? =)

yes please light

Sorry for changing back and forth, it was due to number of sign-ups. Here's what happens with framer in this game (and possibly with epicmafia too) :

Framer IS mafia (there's one vanilla mafia and one framer mafia). Meaning that the framer is a normal mafia member, conversing with the other mafia member and deciding who to kill, but simply has an additional power.

Let me know if there are any more questions on this.

So if I'm correct that leaves us with 1 Bodyguard, 1 Vanilla Mafia, and 1 Framer Mafia as the remaining power roles?

ok i got confused because the original post was never updated, it still says there's two mafia, and one framer.

Yes.

Correct. The game has:

1 Vanilla Mafia
1 Framer Mafia
1 Cop
1 Bodyguard
3 Vanilla Townies

The original post says there are 2 Mafia Members, and the Framer quote says that the Framer is Mafia, thus one of them.

yea I was haveing the same problem as thunder on that one

I'm not well and heading to bed, so I'm going to have to vote no lynch too.

Back from my friends! Sorry guys it's was a 2 hour drive!

No problem, Yami! Welcome back!

I'm gonna go No Lynch

Ok so I re-read from post one and I still don't have any solid suspicions yet.
I have two soft suspects, agentayu and Rei, but we will see.

For now, I will also vote no lynch.

and now I think I'm gonna take a bit of a nap so I can hopefully start feeling better.

GM Note: Names in the spoiler below are by order of voting, and only to make it more interesting. I would have liked a game with clues, actually, but this is too short a game for it.

Spoiler:

time to sit back and wait.

Ari-Chan wrote:and now I think I'm gonna take a bit of a nap so I can hopefully start feeling better.

Hope you feel better!