How I Met Your Mother Mafia TOWNIES WIN!!!

At least if you're truly a townie, it's a good thing to be suspected of fool. You avoid getting mislynched

And now I'm confused again. I won't ask who if you'd rather not say for now, but how can you have a fool suspect when no one's even said anything related to the game so far except us two?

Basically based on past game experiences with certain players which could have them be either mafia or a third party role even though nothing game related has happened yet besides the two of us so far.

Like I said until I'm proven otherwise by mafia killing the Fool or IF (Natasha please clarify if you can) Fool appears guilty to cop and cop is comfortable to come out during anytime during the game on whoever is guilty and what not.

Because we don't get wills or last words in this game, we heavily depend on cop right now for finding the guilty parties. Since with Lily (Rei) gone, that leaves us with 2 townies, cop, and doc [4] with 2 mafia and a fool [3].

Which means for cop: 3 possible innocents and 2 possible guilty for sure. I'm still not sure if Fool would appear guilty or innocent to cop.

*Goes back to look at the roles in the game*

OH! AND we can't forget about the Hooker! They can block ANY village aligned night play which can also mess with us.

Sorry for posting three times in a row:

That means:

2 - Townies
2 - Mafia
1 - Hooker [Mafia Aligned]
1 - Fool
1 - Cop
1 - Doc

WHICH MEANS (upon Rei's Death) we're left with:

2 - Mafia
1 - Hooker [Mafia Aligned]
1 - Townie
1 - Fool
1 - Cop
1 - Doc

And I am claiming to be that last 100% vanilla townie since that's what I am, which means everyone else has a power role. The question is now which role does everyone else have since only 2 of you are Townie aligned with me.

The hooker is one of the mafia. The fool shows up as innocent, not guilty. =)

"The hooker is one of the mafia."

Meaning of the 2 mafia = 1 is 100% mafia and 1 is hooker. Yes?

I think so, should be like when you were Framer/Mafia. I asked about it during sign-ups.

Well it's up to the cop, if they've found anything interesting, they can consider coming out. If they're lucky, they found the Hooker mafia, the doctor will continue protecting them, they will keep investigating, and all is well.

If they found the other mafia, at least we'll still be a mafia down and hope we narrow it down successfully.

If they found an innocent... Better stay hidden a while longer

Exactly. Though if cop does find an innocent it could be the Fool since Fool will appear innocent to cop. Which means DEFINITELY DON'T LYNCH that person. Let Mafia kill them and hope they're the fool and NOT the vanilla townie.

So with the clarification:

3 - Townies
2 - Mafia [1 is Hooker]
1 - Cop
1 - Doc
1 - Fool

With Rei dead:

2 - Townies
2 - Mafia [1 is Hooker]
1 - Cop
1 - Doc
1 - Fool

List:

I think that if the cop finds an innocent, it's sort of a given not to lynch that person. Fool or not. xD

Just stating the obvious regardless as a reminder if things get more confusing for others. xD

Anyways, to sum up my thoughts, here's my suggestion to cop.

Found a guilty? Out them. A counterclaim won't be as successful at this point because we can afford a mislynch. Later in the game, it will be harder to prove it.

Found an innocent? Note it and stay hidden.

Agreed.

so any ideas on what to do?? no one seem fishy to me yet

Well we could either go ahead and lynch seeing as we can still seem to afford one right now. Or we could go no lynch to tired to actually think right now so I'm going to bed night all.

Personally, I'm thinking no lynch if the cop doesn't come out. Why not just buy them more time? We can afford a mislynch, but there's still a chance of hitting the fool, not sure it's worth the risk right now.

Well, definitely NOT going to lynch with very little reasoning especially since there is a risk for lynching the fool. I don't want to help a third party player.

Since we haven't heard from cop yet. I'm currently voting no lynch.

well for cop to come out would be stupid since we have a hooker in the game...

for now i will also vote no lynch.

What if they found the hooker though, and end up dying tonight before they tell us? It's all about what risk you're willing to take with a no last words game. Risk being blocked after, or risk taking your investigation to your grave?

But until I hear anything from a cop, I vote No Lynch as I suggested.

It could be plain mafia member too, either way it is definitely a risk the cop to weigh in on what they would do.

untill the cop finds more info, we do need to be safe No lynch

*le sigh*

Color change to green remember?

She did. It's a darker green.

No lynch- AgentAyu, Light, Thunderdome, Swifty

*leans close into the screen and turns screen backlight way up*

That's a green?!?! Geez, bright green = no questioning!!!! Oh well, your game your call.

I know no last words, but if I die during a Night phase can I still post the:

 ?